Man accused in fatal beating of 94-year-old neighbor pleads not guilty to murder

By Kelly Wheeler, City News Service

A Ramona man accused in the beating death of his 94-year-old neighbor pleaded not guilty Friday to a first-degree murder charge and was ordered held on $3.5 million bail.

Deputy District Attorney David Williams III said the victim — Mary Jean Eskridge — believed Gary Allen Thomas was a trusted friend and allowed her 63-year-old neighbor to spend the night in the guest bedroom of her mobile home the night of April 30.

The next morning, Thomas grabbed a hammer out of a toolbox in the victim’s kitchen, proceeded down the hall and beat Eskridge to death as she slept, the prosecutor alleged.

Friends and relatives of the victim sobbed as Williams outlined the crime to El Cajon Superior Court Judge Charles Ervin.

“This defendant’s willingness to use a position of trust to attack and kill the victim in this case demonstrates how dangerous he is to the community,” Williams said.

Eskridge was a long-standing resident of the Ramona Terrace Estates mobile home park, he said.

Thomas’ attorney said her client had lived for about six years at Ramona Terrace Estates in the 1200 block of H Street, where he was arrested Wednesday afternoon.

Eskridge, who was still active in church and senior center activities, was found in a bedroom of her mobile home about 11:30 a.m. Tuesday by paramedics responding to an activated medical alert bracelet.

Authorities declined to disclose a possible motive for the slaying.

The District Attorney’s Office is asking anyone with knowledge of Thomas’ background or history to contact San Diego Crime Stoppers at 888-580-8477.

Eskridge, a professional dancer in the big band era, was the longtime owner of Jean’s Dance Studio in Spring Valley. The studio is now run by her daughter. The victim also had three sons.

Thomas, who faces 26 years to life in prison if convicted, is due back at the El Cajon courthouse on May 17 for a preliminary hearing.

Related posts:

  1. Ramona man, 63, arrested in 94-year-old woman’s death
  2. Terrace Estates residents recall 94-year-old’s joys of life
  3. Kurtenbach pleads not guilty to second-degree murder in house explosion
  4. Officials investigate death at Terrace Estates
  5. Former special ed teacher’s aide, 69, pleads not guilty to molestation charges

Short URL:

Posted by Maureen Robertson on May 4 2012. Filed under News, Ramona, Sheriff/Fire. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0. You can leave a response or trackback to this entry

1 Comment for “Man accused in fatal beating of 94-year-old neighbor pleads not guilty to murder”

  1. june

    September 19th, 2012 crime alert: "Local family catches caretakers' abuse of autistic son on camera" seen on channel 8 san diego news Sept 19th 2012. Just horrific! Why is there such a rise in abuse of autistic people? What does this say about the soul beat of our society?

    VALLEY CENTER — Video surveillance showing a 23-year-old Valley Center man with autism being beaten hundreds of times over a three-week period by two caregivers led sheriff’s deputies to arrest one man Wednesday night. An arrest warrant has been issued for the other caregiver.
    The Sheriff’s Department learned of the suspected abuse on Aug. 29, Sgt. Mark Varnau said. The victim is nonverbal and severely autistic.
    His family alleged that two hired caregivers were captured on video abusing the victim in August, Varnau said. The family had installed a video surveillance system in the man’s bedroom just prior to the assaults being discovered, he said.
    The two caregivers were employed by the family for more than two years.
    It’s not known how long the victim was abused, Varnau said. Because of his autism, he had no ability to communicate to others what was happening, the sergeant said.
    Detectives reviewed more than 2,000 video recordings before obtaining arrest warrants for Michael Dale Garritson, 50, of Valley Center, and Matthew Alexander McDuffie, 27, of San Diego.
    McDuffie was arrested Wednesday night by detectives from the sheriff’s fugitive apprehension unit.
    Garritson has not been apprehended, and sheriff’s officials asked for the public’s help in locating him. Anyone with information is asked to contact the Sheriff’s Department at (858) 565-5200 or Crime Stoppers at (888) 580-8477

Leave a Reply